The Two Deaths of Ruth Lyle

Nick Louth

When one of your favourite authors ends a great series, and you wonder what they are going to come up with next, this is the type of response you really want.

Detective Inspector Jan Talantire and her team work in a Major Investigation Team of Devon and Cornwall Police. What they face in this story is a unique and baffling crime.

Ruth Lyle was a 16 year old girl when she was killed on the alter of a church 50 years ago.

When a woman is killed in the same way, in the now converted church, on the anniversary it is the start of an investigation that will span half a century.

It’s not just the location and manner of death which are identical. The woman killed today has the same name as the original victim, the same date of birth, and her birth certificate.

As far as debuts for a new series goes this is second to none.

The crime is clever and left me intrigued up till the very last page.

Talentire is a great character. Nearly 40, newly single and struggling with trying to establish a life balance that would actually give her a chance on the dating scene.

She is driven as a detective, and doesn’t take any heed of pressures from above, or below, when she is on the right track.

The supporting characters of her team, especially the newly appointed digital expert Primrose, are going to be great to watch develop over the series.

But what really steals the show is the setting. Small town crime on the North Devon coast needs all the skills of those investigated in the big cities. Without overlapping CCTV, with sketchy mobile phone coverage, and with the infrastructure difficulties of rural policing, it is more old school than some of the stories set in the cities, and for me that makes it all the more readable.

Let’s hope this is the start of another brilliant series.

Publisher: Canelo Crime. Pages: 326. Publishing date: 2nd May 2024 Audiobook 10 hours 9 minutes narrated by Mandy Weston

Crow Moon. Suzy Ashley

If Hitchcock had directed a film starting Miss Marple this would have been the plot.

Set in a remote Scottish village, around the time of the crow moon, the plot is set in the current day but has at its base ancient folklore.

Martha Strangeways is a reporter who is on extended leave following the death of her young twins in a house fire. She has a teenage son from a previous relationship, and unknown to her he had a dabble in the occult with two friends, one of which is found dead in the woods with a verse from an poem written in his back.

The police carry out a major investigation but Martha, who is carrying out her own unofficial investigation, isn’t sure they are doing enough.

The Police Senior Investigator recognises the benefits of having a renowned journalist, who lives locally, on his side, and agrees to share information with her as long as she is not working as a journalist.

She isn’t, she’s investigating because she’s made the connection that the police don’t want to take seriously, and she’s worried for other teenagers, including her son.

When a girl, another of the three teenagers who dabbled in the occult goes missing Martha starts to make spurious links, and disagrees with the police when they think they know who is to blame.

The setting for this book, and the premise of the story, are dark and could have been written by James Herbert. As I’ve already said the main character of Martha could have come from the pen of Agatha Christie.

That simple formula has produced a cracking story.

As far a debut books go this is one of, if not the best, I’ve read.

Publisher: Orenda Books. Pages: 402.

Audio Book length. 10 hours 18 mins. Narrator Sarah Barron

Turf War. Mark Romain

A new author to me, and the start of a five book series.

Before I did a bit of research on the author I already knew I was going to find he had served as a Police Officer, and was not surprised to find he was an experienced Met Officer who had done two stints on Homicide.

You really can’t write a book that catches the essence of an investigation this well without having “earned the t-shirt”

When the leader of one of three gangs, struggling to take overall control of an area of London, decides to hire outsiders to hit a rivals operation, he only has one thing in mind.

Blaming another gang and a tarting a turf war between his rivals.

DCI Jack Tyler’s team are in the middle of the investigation, into the killing of three Turkish Gangsters when he becomes aware that the incident may be linked to an operation being run by his friend, Tony Dillon, in the Organised Crime Group.

To cap Tyler’s day off his ex-wife is caught in a Violent Steaming incident on a train.

The incidents are all linked by different gangs, and the individuals in the gangs.

The way Mark aroma in has written this makes it a real page turner.

The plot of the crimes, and the characters for each, overlap like a well planned Venn Diagram.

Tyler is undoubtedly the main character but Dillon, and several of the gang members are given almost equal time in the book, and the story unfolds with the reader getting an almost 360 degree insight into what is happening.

The politics, and democratic, of each gang is really well portrayed.

The thoughts, observations, and concerns of Tyler from the policing side, and the Meeks brothers from the gang side, are really well written and take the reader right into the heart of the story.

I loved the story, the characters and ten way it was written, the next book, Jacks Back, is already on my Kindle and has gone straight to the top of my to-be-read list

Print length: 674 pages.

A Soul For A Soul. Carol Wyer

Carol Wyer has done it again.

This is the fifth book in this series and everyone of them has had me gripped from the very start, and this is no different.

Although this book is part of a series Carol does a great job of filling in the skeleton of the running theme in the first two chapters. So, anybody reading this as a standalone novel will not be left totally in the dark.

What’s on the back of the book, or in this case on the Amazon page

DCI Kate Young never meant to shoot Superintendent John Dickson at the reservoir that night—even if, as a scheming corrupt cop and head of the shady syndicate, he probably had it coming. But now Kate has photographic evidence that someone else knows her terrible secret…

Tormented by guilt and the voices of the dead, Kate is desperate to unmask the rest of the corrupt officers before her own sins catch up with her. When DI Harriet Khatri, awaiting trial for the murder of Kate’s mentor, claims she was framed by Dickson’s syndicate, Kate reluctantly agrees to help in the hope of finding answers.

Meanwhile, DI Emma Donaldson finds herself on the hunt for a double murderer—a man who incapacitates his victims with a powerful narcotic called Devil’s Breath. Desperate to measure up to her role-model boss, Emma finds herself hurled into the deep end in more ways than one…

While Kate’s grip on reality wavers and the syndicate closes in, and with the mystery killer taking a special interest in Emma, could this be the case that defeats both detectives?

What I think

Kate Young lost her husband to a murderer. He was an investigative journalist and he was on to a ring of sex offenders.

At least one of which was a high ranking police officer.

Every investigation since his murder has almost been a “side hustle” as Kates main focus has been catching his killer and busting the sex ring.

I have questioned her mental health from the start, she hears voices, mainly that of her husband but latterly the dead Superintendent Dickinson.

It’s like having an Angel on one shoulder, and a devil on the other.

What I began to realise, or for my own opinion on, was that actually she was just hypothesis building, the voices she was hearing was just a manifestation of her own thinking.

Police shouldn’t investigate with a bias, and Kates way of building her case was to have the two voices neutralising each other to make sure she was getting things right.

Haven’t we all had that little voice saying “one more drink” and another saying “no you’re going to regret it in the morning”

This book brings that story to a head and draws a line underneath it.

But will it silence the voices?

Is this the end of the DCI Kate Young series?

I sincerely hope not, but Carol Wyer has left us with an ending that might mean it is.

It’s not a cliffhanger, it’s the end of a running story, the logical place to conclude and for Kate to walk away. But the last few lines give me hope that we may see her again.

What a series, what a book, what an ending.

Print length 381 pages. Publisher Thomas and Mercer.

The Detectives Daughter. Erica Spindler

I’ve been through a bit of a reading lull recently and was finding it hard to get into books, unusual for me as I’ll tend to read at least 2 a week.


I googled authors similar to Greg Iles, my favourite US crime author, and Erica Spindler came up at the top of several reviewers suggestions.
I wasn’t disappointed.


The Detectives Daughter is my first of her books, and it held me from page one.


A fast paced story which never wonders into the fanciful, or impossible.
The story of two murders linked by two families and two detectives.
The first led to the older detective’s untimely resignation and death. The crime he never solved.


His daughter, now also a detective has always wanted to look at the crime again, but when a murder brings some of the same people into the spotlight she has her chance.


Will it finish her career of also.


Based in New Orleans Detective Quinn Conners is a no nonsense murder detective. Following in her father’s footsteps she deals with crime in Americas Deep South.

Called to a shooting at a party it first appears to be an open-an-shut case, but soon things start to look a bit more complicated.

One of the families involved was also involved in the case that haunted her father to his grave.

Although years apart the cases seem to be connected.

The problem is there’s some New Orleans Old Family money involved.

I have to say that I thought the ending to the plot was a bit telegraphed, until my hypothesis proved only partially right. But this didn’t spoil the story. In fact it added to it because all of a sudden the plot took another turn, and the story that gripped me from the start held on to me tightly until the end.

Publisher: Double Shot Press. Pages: 458

Bad Blood. Angela Marsons

I’ve been with this series since the start, and dispite my old bias that I always thought books lost their impact the longer the series went on, this series just keeps getting better and better.

In an unusual chain of events DI Kim Stone is sent to a murder, only to find that the body isn’t actually a dead…….yet!

To all intents and purposes, to the point it’s even confused the pathologist, it looks dead, but suddenly somebody realises the man is still alive.

He doesn’t survive long and Kim, and the team, start a murder investigation that has them scratching their collective heads.

When another body turns up, killed and posed in a similar manner, there appears to be no link between the two victims.

But there is, and as the team start to put the pieces of the puzzle together hey begin to build a list of suspects.

Based on revenge, but revenge for who, and by who. The killer has an agenda, and is the epitome of the “a dish best served cold” killer.

But it’s not just the murders that Kim is having problems with. One of her team is struggling. They made a mistake and are suffering for it. Their work is affected, as is their home life.

But what really gets on Kim’s nerves is that they didn’t feel they could share the problem with her and the rest of the team.

Angela Marsons writes these books as if she’s been in an incident room. The procedures, are there but rules are to be broken, and not just by Stone. Things get done because the team use their knowledge and experience to push boundaries.

The relationships in the team. Stones trusty DS Bryant acting as the filter between her and the DC’s, and at times, her and the public. The DC’s both loving working with her but scared of her wrath hence things aren’t going well.

Even though stone hasn’t got a family she is the matriarch of her little Police team. So when one of the DC’s falls out of favour it affects everybody.

He humour is also spot on, the gallows humour of the emergency service first responders is sometimes overlooked, by others, but not here.

The interaction between Stone and Keats, the Pathologist, had me chuckling….I mean, he did think a living man was dead.

One of the things I love about these books is the way Angela introduced that element of doubt early in the series, by killing off one of the main characters. There’s not guarantee that everything’s going to turn out rosy. So you can’t take it for granted that bridges will be mended.

I saw a post on TikTok the other day where a blogger had started a thread, “ Which books do you wish you could read again for the first time” I didn’t even have to think about it. The Kim Stone series. From book 1, Silent Scream, right up to this latest instalment, all in one binge.

But now we might just have something to look forward to in that respect. Angela Marsons announced a few weeks ago that the series has been taken by a TV company that produces dramas for the BBC.

So maybe we will get to enjoy them all over again.

Pages: 415. Publisher: Bookouture. Available now. Audiobook. 8 hours 12 minutes. Narrator: Jan Cramer.

AMZ: https://geni.us/B0CFK57VD9social

Apple: https://ow.ly/iQUQ50Q6JbI

Kobo: https://ow.ly/yIkI50Q6JbQ

Google: https://ow.ly/CBLS50Q6Jc0

The Alter Girls. Patricia Gibney

I can’t believe we’re already at book 13 in this series.

Don’t worry if you haven’t read the others because this can be read as a standalone and is still a fantastic read.

The ongoing stories involving Detective Lottie Park, her team, and her family add to the series massively, but the main story in each book is the real star.

In this book two young girls go missing on a snowy day. The only problem is nobody really notices they’re missing for a good few hours.

Both girls are connected to the church through the choir and serve as alter girls, both are very young, still in primary school.

When the first girl turns up dead in the Cathedral grounds people naturally start suspect the involvement of somebody in the clergy. A bias that has riddled the church for years.

When the second girl is found in similar circumstances the Catholic Fathers come under even more suspicion.

Lottie can’t afford any type of bias as her team start the investigation.

The families of both girls also have their secrets, but the main person Lottie would suspect, one of the girls fathers, is in prison

Nobody writes crime fiction better than Patricia Gibney.

She relates the frustrations of the investigation team with unerring realism.

When instinct is telling you there is something wrong, but there is no evidence. When old biases rear their head, but you daren’t act on them because people will think you’re going for the obvious, easy hit.

Gibney never shies away from putting her characters through the mill. She never avoids a difficult subject. In the Alter Girls she addresses some of the concerns people have around the clergy. She looks at the secrets kept behind closed doors in, what should be the sanctuary, of the family home.

And all the way through she shows the minefield that is building hypothesis during an investigation. It is absolutely compelling.

The book is just over 500 pages long but every word is used well and is relevant to the current story, or the ongoing stories of the main characters.

As close as it could be this was a “pick it up and read from start to finish” for me. In fact if I hadn’t have to go to work, it would have been.

Pages 504. Publisher: Bookouture. Audiobook 13 h 35m. Narrator Michele Moran

The Scorned. Alex Khan

A good Police Procedural novel with strong characters.

At times this book is a tough read and contains triggers for anybody who has suffered domestic abuse.

A tough Asian Lady who has run away from her own “arranged” , and abusive marriage is now a Detective Sergeant working on serious crimes. Moomy Ali is a great character.

When two women, with no apparently link are brutally murdered, within hours of each other Moomy and her team are tasked to investigate.

Why have the Home Office sent an observer in to watch over the team, even before the first victim is identified.

The teams fears that they are being used as some form of political pawn doesn’t stop them carrying out an investigation that uncovers a disturbing scenario.

There appears to be a group of people being manipulated to kill, born on their hatred of women.

During the investigation they uncover bigoted hate in various forms, which are unfortunately very realistic and believable.

But which group, and which leader are responsible for the killings.

As much as this book is a great story it’s also a sad reflection on elements of today’s society.

Frighteningly realistic, and at times hard to read, it’s a great book.

Pages 377. Publisher: Hera Release Date: 5th October 2023

Anna O. Matthew Blake

I’ve read a few books with really original plots recently but I think this one stand out.

Anna O is an infamous young lady who was found lying between two people who had stabbed to death. She was asleep, and four years later she still is.

The judiciary wants to put her on trial, but first they need to get her into a fit enough condition to stand trial.

They have her moved to the Abbey sleep clinic on Harley Street and place her under the treatment of Dr Benedict Prince, who has recently published a paper on Resignation Syndrome. (That had me reaching for Google and spending a good hour reading about the syndrome)

From there the plot splits between several characters.

Benedict himself.

His ex wife, who was the first Police Officer on the scene of the murder.

Anna O’s Mom, an ex Shadow Minister, now Vicar , who was, and is, more interested in saving her own reputation than that of her daughter.

Anna’s Dad, a Banker who has little in common with his wife or daughter.

Lola, a blogger and armchair detective that is linked to Anna, and possibly the murders. Her online persona is @Suspect8. Insinuating she was at the scene.

The plot is brilliantly woven from the outlook of each of these characters.

It’s a battle for the truth. Is Anna O a murderer, or a convenient scapegoat.

Can Benedict rouse her from her sleep and have her sufficiently compos mantis enough to tell her story.

The Publishers Gumph


What if your nightmares weren’t really nightmares at all?

We spend an average of 33 years of our lives asleep. But what really happens, and what are we capable of, when we sleep?

Anna Ogilvy was a budding twenty-five-year-old writer with a bright future. Then, one night, she stabbed two people to death with no apparent motive–and hasn’t woken up since. Dubbed “Sleeping Beauty” by the tabloids, Anna’s condition is a rare psychosomatic disorder known to neurologists as “resignation syndrome.”

Dr. Benedict Prince is a forensic psychologist and an expert in the field of sleep-related homicides. His methods are the last hope of solving the infamous “Anna O'”case and waking Anna up so she can stand trial. But he must be careful treating such a high-profile suspect–he’s got career secrets and a complicated personal life of his own.

As Anna shows the first signs of stirring, Benedict must determine what really happened and whether Anna should be held responsible for her crimes.

Only Anna knows the truth about that night, but only Benedict knows how to discover it. And they’re both in danger from what they find out.

What I thought

It’s a real page turner of a book. I’d never heard of Resignation Syndrome before, and I’ve found out that it’s a relatively newly diagnosed condition, but I can see many more authors using it as the spine of a plot.

The plot itself is really good and with one exception I didn’t second guess where the story was going.

At 448 pages it’s a bit long but not a page is wasted.

I can’t wait to see what Matthew Blake writes next.

Vengeance. J.K Flynn

I recently read and reviewed The Art Merchant by J.K Flynn and raved about it. I said then I couldn’t wait for the next instalment and I was lucky enough to get my hands on a copy this week.

It didn’t disappoint.

Flynn has taken DS. Esther Penman to the next level.

Now a recovering alcoholic who has been sober for over fifty days things are going well.

But her reputation is still there like a dark shadow. Everybody knows she’s the best Detective on the force, but her past erratic behaviour, and tendency to wake up in strange bedrooms, is tarnishing her, and her DCI is making her life difficult.

Thankfully her DI, Jared Wilcox, is on her side but how much can he protect her.

When they start to investigate a murder Esther uncovers a link to a missing person that the Met are dealing with.

From there spurious links start to surface to other crimes and strange occurrences.

Jared is a good DI but he knows Esther is the brains of the team, and is happy to run with her instincts, even when she has a bit of a wobble.

The title of the book gives away the motive of the crimes but the way the plot develops kept me totally enthralled.

Esther Penman has established herself of one of my favourite characters in the Crime Thriller World.

What the publishers say

A MURDERED EXECUTIVE. 

A MISSING STOCKBROKER.

A DRUG WORTH BILLIONS. 

When a body turns up in a Belfield alleyway, Detective Sergeant Esther Penman quickly realises there’s more to it than simple homicide. With links to a missing London stockbroker, and the dead man’s firm on the brink of launching a new medicine worth billions, there’s plenty of motive for murder. 

Meanwhile, Esther has trouble of her own to deal with. Having recently made an enemy of one of the city’s most ruthless criminals, she knows she has to watch her back. But as she begins to unravel the web of intrigue surrounding the alleyway murder, she can’t shake the unsettling sense that she herself is becoming a target… 

Can Esther stay one step ahead of her enemies in her hunt for the killer? 

Find out in Vengeance, the thrilling sequel to The Art Merchant.

What I think.

A no brainier recommendation. A cracking book.

Brilliant characters, especially Esther.

A realistic crime set against a realistic background.

And best of all, it was every bit as good as the first in the series, if not better.